Best Paddle alternatives for SaaS (2026): 9 merchants of record compared on cost, payouts and switching

Compare 9 Paddle alternatives that act as your merchant of record: fees at $1k-$50k MRR, payouts, dispute fees and how to move subscriptions off Paddle.

BY SANDRO ZWEIG

Summarize with AI

No headings found on page

The closest Paddle alternatives, the ones that also act as your merchant of record (MoR), are Polar, Creem, Dodo Payments, Lemon Squeezy, Stripe Managed Payments, FastSpring, PayPro Global, Freemius and tiun. Stripe Billing, Chargebee and Recurly are billing tools: with them you become the seller and handle VAT and sales tax yourself. On a $29 subscription at $10,000 MRR, Paddle costs $672 a month in our model, and the six alternatives we modelled range from $587 to $888.

Stay on Paddle if its strengths match your business. Paddle charges one rate, 5% + 50¢, with no surcharge for international cards or subscriptions. It offers 18 payment methods, including iDEAL | Wero, Pix, UPI, Alipay and WeChat Pay. Sales teams can send invoices that buyers pay by bank transfer or card. And since 20 October 2026 Paddle has an AI toolkit, with Docs and Billing MCP servers that work in Claude Code, Codex, Cursor and Gemini CLI.

Reasons teams look for a Paddle alternative

Everything in this section comes from Paddle's own pricing page, help centre, developer docs, terms and blog.

  • The 50¢ fixed fee weighs on low prices. On a $29 subscription, 5% + 50¢ is 6.7% of the sale; on a $9 product it is 10.6%. Paddle invites sellers with products under $10 to contact it for bespoke pricing.

  • Payouts are monthly. Paddle starts the payout run on the 1st and sends the money by the 15th. The minimum threshold is $100, and you can't withdraw on demand.

  • Each chargeback costs 20 USD, GBP or EUR (40 CAD or AUD). Paddle also charges the fee when a pre-chargeback alert arrives, and keeps it when it wins the dispute. Its dispute defence is automated and doesn't accept evidence from sellers.

  • Converted sales carry an FX margin. Under clause 7.1 of Paddle's terms (updated 6 October 2026), a sale that needs converting into your account's payment currency is converted at the mid-market rate plus 2% for USD, EUR and GBP, 2.5% for CZK, DKK, NOK and THB, and 3% for all other currencies. A margin of up to 1.5% can also apply when your payout currency differs from your balance currency.

  • Native usage-based billing isn't available yet. Paddle's 20 October announcement puts a private preview in early 2027 and points usage-based businesses to integrations with outside billing providers until then.

  • SEPA Direct Debit isn't offered. It is absent from the 18 methods in Paddle's developer docs, which confirm subscription support for cards, Apple Pay and Google Pay.

Some of these limits apply to the alternatives too, tiun included. The table and provider sections below show where.

Merchants of record compared

Provider

Legal seller (country)

Base fee

Surcharges

Payout fee and schedule

Dispute fee

Usage billing

Imports subscriptions from Paddle?

Best for

Paddle (reference)

Paddle.com Market Ltd (UK); Paddle Payments Ltd (Ireland) for UK and Isle of Man sellers; Paddle.com Inc. for US buyers

5% + 50¢

None

Typically free to a local account in the balance currency; $/€/£15 SWIFT otherwise. Monthly, sent by the 15th, $100 minimum

$20, also on alerts, not refunded if won

Private preview early 2027

n/a


tiun

tiun AG (Switzerland)

2.9% + 30¢

+0.5% on subscription payments; international cards included

1.5%. Monthly, $200 minimum

$35, also on alerts, not refunded if won

Time-based (per minute or session)

No

Lowest modelled cost; login and customer database included

Polar

Polar Software, Inc. (US, Delaware law)

Starter 5% + 50¢ (free); Pro 3.8% + 40¢ ($20/mo); Growth 3.6% + 35¢ ($100/mo); Scale 3.4% + 30¢ ($400/mo)

+1.5% non-US cards

Stripe's fees: $2/month + 0.25% + 25¢ per payout, plus cross-border fees of 0.25% in the EU and up to 1% elsewhere. Withdraw when you choose

$15 in fee docs (terms: $25 alert fee, up to $30 per incident)

Yes: meters, credits, unit pricing

Not in public docs

Usage-based and AI products

Creem

Armitage Labs OÜ (Estonia)

3.9% + 40¢

None for international cards

$7/€7 or 1%, whichever is higher. 1st and 15th, 50 USD/EUR minimum

$25

Yes: metered usage, credits

No

An EU-incorporated seller with one flat rate

Dodo Payments

Dodo Payments Inc. and affiliates (Delaware law)

4% + 40¢ (US domestic)

+1.5% international; +0.5% subscriptions and usage; +3% PayPal or BNPL

$5 on payouts under $1,000; $25 SWIFT. 18th and 4th, $100 minimum

$30

Yes: usage, credits, seat add-ons

Yes, assisted, saved cards only

Many local payment methods

Lemon Squeezy

Sold through Link, LLC, formerly Lemon Squeezy LLC (US)

5% + 50¢

+1.5% outside the US; +1.5% PayPal; +0.5% subscriptions

Free to US banks, 1% to non-US banks. Paid 14th and 28th after a 13-day hold, $50 minimum

$15

Yes: metered

Yes, assisted

Licence-key products and a done-for-you Paddle migration

Stripe Managed Payments

Stripe; buyers see "Sold through Link" (US)

3.5% on top of Stripe processing (US cards 2.9% + 30¢)

+1.5% international cards; +0.7% Stripe Billing on subscriptions

Your Stripe account's payouts

$15 dispute received fee (US)

Not documented

No documented path

Teams already on Stripe Checkout

FastSpring

Bright Market, LLC dba FastSpring (US), or FastSpring B.V. (Netherlands) for cards processed by a European acquirer

Quote only

Quote only

2.5% FX fee if store and payout currencies differ. 15th and month-end by default, $100 minimum, 45-day hold before the first payout

Not published

Managed subscriptions you rebill on demand

Yes, card-token import from your current provider (Paddle not named)

Established software companies negotiating a rate

PayPro Global

PayPro Global, Inc. (Toronto, Canada)

Quote only

Quote only

Payoneer $2, US ACH $3, wire $21, PayPal free in US/CA and 2% elsewhere (max $20). Monthly, around the 15th

Not published

Metered billing via catalog and API

Yes, encrypted import from a PCI DSS provider (Paddle not named)

Software vendors that want a negotiated, all-features-included rate

Freemius

Freemius, Inc. (US)

3.8% + 50¢ plus gateway fees (Freemius cites a 3.5% average)

+2.3% for WordPress products

No payout fee. Monthly, $100 minimum

Processor's $15-20 on lost disputes

Prepaid credits

Migration help; saved-card transfer not stated

WordPress plugins and licensed software

Billing tools that leave tax with you

Tool

Who is the seller

What the tool costs

Tax

Merchant-of-record option

Stripe Billing + Stripe Tax

You

Billing 0.7% of billing volume; Stripe Tax Basic 0.5% per transaction where you're registered; plus processing (US cards 2.9% + 30¢)

Stripe Tax calculates and collects; registrations and filings need Tax Complete (from $90/month)

Switch to Stripe Managed Payments

Chargebee

You

Pricing page shows $0 + 0.80% or $99 + 0.65% of monthly invoicing volume, plus your gateway's fees

Built-in tax plus Avalara and Anrok integrations

Reach integration (private beta)

Recurly

You

Starter: $249/month + 0.9% of billing volume, first $40K a month included; plus your gateway's fees

Built-in tax calculation powered by Avalara; Avalara AvaTax or Vertex for more

Reach integration

With these tools you pay a processor separately, register for VAT and sales tax where you cross thresholds, and file and remit returns yourself or through a partner. Chargebee and Recurly can connect to Reach, a separate company that then acts as the merchant of record.

What each option costs compared with Paddle

The model: a $29 monthly subscription charged in USD, half of it paid with non-US cards, paid out in USD to a US bank account, with payout fees included. Fees are calculated on the $29 before tax, with no refunds or disputes. Where a provider sells plans, the cheapest plan at each revenue level is shown.

Provider

$1k MRR

$10k MRR

$50k MRR

Paddle

$67

$672

$3,362

tiun

$59 (−$9)

$587 (−$86)

$2,934 (−$428)

Creem

$67 (−$0.45)

$623 (−$50)

$3,113 (−$249)

Polar (cheapest plan at each level)

$79 Starter (+$12)

$639 Pro (−$34)

$2,999 Growth (−$364)

Dodo Payments

$76 (+$9)

$663 (−$9)

$3,315 (−$47)

Lemon Squeezy

$80 (+$13)

$797 (+$125)

$3,987 (+$625)

Stripe Managed Payments

$89 (+$22)

$888 (+$216)

$4,442 (+$1,080)

Differences are calculated before rounding. A few details sit behind the numbers:

  • Dodo's figures include its $5 fee on each payout under $1,000, which applies to both monthly payouts at $1k MRR.

  • Creem pays out twice a month at $7 or 1%, whichever is higher. Polar's figures assume one withdrawal a month.

  • Every sale is charged in USD, so no currency-conversion margin is included for any provider. If you price in local currencies, conversion costs come on top for several providers, including Paddle's 2-3% margin under clause 7.1.

  • Paddle, Creem, Lemon Squeezy, Polar and Stripe Managed Payments take their percentage from the tax-inclusive total, so on sales that carry VAT they cost more than shown here.

  • Stripe Managed Payments payouts are assumed free, as standard Stripe payouts are.

  • FastSpring and PayPro Global quote privately, and Freemius's gateway fees vary, so they are left out.

Dispute fees aren't included, and they change the order. At a 1% dispute rate on $10k MRR (about 3.4 disputes a month), Polar Pro at $15 per dispute comes to $690, below tiun's $707 at $35 per dispute, and Creem at $25 per dispute comes to $709, level with tiun. Polar's terms allow higher dispute charges than its fee docs, so check yours.

The alternatives one by one

tiun

Best for: SaaS and AI products that want the lowest fee in this comparison, with login and a customer database in the same integration.

Pricing: 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction, +0.5% on subscription payments, international cards included. Payouts are monthly with a 1.5% fee and a $200 minimum. Disputes cost $35 each. As with other MoRs, we can hold a reserve or delay a payout in defined risk cases, and limits can apply until your account is fully verified. Full figures are on tiun.io/pricing.

Where it beats Paddle: tiun is the cheapest option in our model at every level: $59, $587 and $2,934 a month against Paddle's $67, $672 and $3,362. Authentication and the customer database come with the account, and you can set up products from Claude Code or Cursor through our MCP server. We also bill time-based products by the minute or by the session.

Where Paddle is better: Our payouts are monthly like Paddle's, but they carry a 1.5% fee and a $200 minimum, while Paddle's payouts to a local account in your balance currency are typically free. Our $35 dispute fee is the highest flat dispute fee published on this list. Like Paddle, we charge it on pre-chargeback alerts and keep it when a dispute is won, and a lost chargeback comes out of your payout. We have no import from Paddle, so your subscribers re-enter their card at our checkout. We accept cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal and TWINT, without iDEAL, Bancontact, Pix, UPI or Asian wallets. We don't offer sales-assisted or wire-transfer invoices, and we don't yet sell to business buyers in the US (US consumers are fine). tiun AG is a Swiss company, outside the EU, and processes data primarily in Switzerland and the EEA. Our tiun vs Paddle comparison goes feature by feature.

Polar

Best for: usage-based and AI products that need meters, credits and unit pricing today.

Pricing: Four plans, from Starter (free, 5% + 50¢) to Scale ($400 a month, 3.4% + 30¢), with 1.5% extra on non-US cards. Stripe's payout fees are passed through. Polar's fee docs put disputes at $15.

Where it beats Paddle: From about $4k MRR in our model, Polar Pro undercuts Paddle ($34 less at $10k), and Growth is $364 less at $50k. Usage-based billing is live now. You withdraw when you choose, though organisations created since 12 May 2026 wait 7 days for each transaction to settle.

Where Paddle is better: At $1k MRR Polar's cheapest plan costs $12 more a month. Polar doesn't support PayPal. Its public migration guide covers Stripe only; a Paddle card import appears in a draft design document in Polar's engineering handbook.

Creem

Best for: teams that want an EU-incorporated seller and one flat rate.

Pricing: 3.9% + 40¢ with no international card fee or monthly fee. Payouts cost $7/€7 or 1%, whichever is higher. Chargebacks cost $25.

Where it beats Paddle: Cheaper at every level in our model: $0.45 less at $1k, $50 at $10k and $249 at $50k. Payouts come twice a month. The legal seller, Armitage Labs OÜ, is an Estonian company. Metered usage and prepaid credits are supported.

Where Paddle is better: At $1k MRR the two cost about the same. Creem lists fewer payment methods, and funds can be held 7 to 12 days for risk review. Creem's migration tool imports Lemon Squeezy catalogs only, and its docs say active subscriptions can't be moved automatically.

Dodo Payments

Best for: products that sell into markets where local payment methods matter.

Pricing: 4% + 40¢ on US domestic payments, +1.5% international, +0.5% on subscriptions and usage. Disputes cost $30 and refunds $1. Payouts under $1,000 cost $5.

Where it beats Paddle: Dodo says it supports 40+ payment methods, including Klarna, Afterpay, ACH and SEPA Direct Debit (Afterpay, ACH and SEPA for one-time payments only). Its migration docs cover Paddle and move saved cards. Usage, credit and seat billing are supported, and payouts come twice a month.

Where Paddle is better: On cost the two are close: $9 more at $1k MRR, $9 less at $10k, $47 less at $50k. Dodo's dispute fee is $30 to Paddle's $20, and it charges for refunds. Its docs mark PayPal as "temporarily unavailable for new transactions". Dodo's terms of use (clause 4.2) set a rate of 5% + 50¢, above its pricing page.

Lemon Squeezy

Best for: products that rely on licence keys, and sellers who want the Paddle migration done for them.

Pricing: 5% + 50¢, +1.5% outside the US, +1.5% for PayPal, +0.5% on subscriptions. Payouts are free to US banks and 1% to non-US banks.

Where it beats Paddle: Lemon Squeezy migrates products, customers, payment methods, transactions, subscriptions, coupons and licence keys from Paddle. Payouts come twice a month, and metered usage billing is available.

Where Paddle is better: The base rate is the same and the surcharges come on top, which adds $125 a month at $10k MRR. Stripe owns Lemon Squeezy, and its January 2026 update said the goal is an easy migration to Stripe Managed Payments while acknowledging slower support and less frequent product updates. No end date has been announced.

Stripe Managed Payments

Best for: teams already selling through Stripe Checkout or Payment Links from one of the 37 business locations Stripe supports.

Pricing: 3.5% on top of standard Stripe processing, plus Stripe Billing's 0.7% on subscriptions. The 3.5% applies to the full amount including tax. In the US each dispute costs a $15 dispute received fee.

Where it beats Paddle: Everything stays in your Stripe account and dashboard, and buyers can check out with saved Link details.

Where Paddle is better: It is the most expensive option in our model, $216 a month above Paddle at $10k MRR. It works only with Checkout and Payment Links, with no Connect platforms and no subscriptions created outside Checkout. Buyers see Link as the seller, with a LINK.COM* card statement descriptor. If you don't answer a support escalation within 48 hours, Stripe may refund the buyer without your approval. Professional services and services involving a human, such as live 1:1 coaching, aren't eligible.

FastSpring

Best for: established software companies that will negotiate a rate.

Pricing: Quote only. Payouts default to twice a month, after a 45-day hold before the first one.

Where it beats Paddle: A wider list of payment methods, including ACH, Klarna Pay Now and SEPA Direct Debit (all on request), and a weekly payout option. FastSpring imports active subscriptions with payment tokens from your current provider, a process it says takes "weeks, not months".

Where Paddle is better: Paddle publishes its rate and has no 45-day hold on the first payout.

PayPro Global

Best for: software vendors that want a negotiated, all-features-included rate.

Pricing: Quote only. Payouts are monthly, usually on the 15th, with fees from $2 (Payoneer) to $21 (wire).

Where it beats Paddle: PayPro Global cites 70+ payment methods and 140+ currencies, and imports subscriptions with payment data from any PCI DSS-certified provider.

Where Paddle is better: Paddle publishes its rate, and its payouts to a local account in your balance currency are typically free.

Freemius

Best for: WordPress plugins, themes and software sold with licence keys.

Pricing: 3.8% + 50¢ plus payment gateway fees, which Freemius puts at 3.5% on average; WordPress products pay 2.3% more. The percentage steps down once monthly gross sales pass $50,000, to 0.5% above $100,000. No payout fee.

Where it beats Paddle: Licensing is built in, the rate falls at high volume, and there's no dispute fee unless you lose.

Where Paddle is better: Below $50,000 a month, 3.8% + 50¢ plus a 3.5% average gateway fee comes to about 7.3% + 50¢ before any fixed gateway fee, above Paddle's 5% + 50¢.

Leaving Paddle

Paddle's guide says that after security checks on the new provider's PCI-compliant vault, it transfers payment method details "within 2 weeks". You export subscriber data from the Paddle dashboard and send it to the new provider yourself.

Dodo Payments' migration docs add three details. Paddle stores cards with IXOPAY (TokenEx), which runs at most two exports per account: one at the start and one for customers added during the switch. And Apple Pay, Google Pay and other wallet payment methods can't move between processors, so those customers add a card again. Dodo puts a migration at 3 to 4 weeks end to end.

Dodo Payments and Lemon Squeezy document assisted imports from Paddle that include saved cards and subscriptions. FastSpring and PayPro Global import subscriptions with payment data from your current provider, though neither names Paddle. Freemius says it moves customer and subscription data from Paddle, without saying whether saved cards move. Polar's public migration guide covers Stripe only, Creem's tool covers Lemon Squeezy catalogs only, and Stripe Managed Payments subscriptions can only be created through Checkout or Payment Links.

tiun has no import tool. Subscribers move by checking out again with us, so you can send new sign-ups to tiun straight away and invite existing subscribers to switch at renewal.

FAQ

What is the cheapest Paddle alternative?

In our model ($29 subscription, half non-US cards, US bank account, no disputes), tiun is the cheapest at $1k, $10k and $50k MRR, at 5.9% of revenue against Paddle's 6.7%. Creem comes next at $1k and $10k, and Polar's Growth plan at $50k. With a 1% dispute rate, Polar Pro becomes the cheapest at $10k MRR.

Is Stripe a merchant of record like Paddle?

Standard Stripe isn't: you are the seller and handle tax yourself, even with Stripe Billing and Stripe Tax. Stripe Managed Payments is. It opened to all digital businesses on 29 April 2026, supports sellers in 37 countries, and shows buyers "Sold through Link" as the seller.

Which Paddle alternative is best for indie hackers?

At $1k MRR, tiun costs $59 a month in our model, Creem $67 and Paddle $67. Polar's Starter plan has no monthly fee, comes to $79 and includes usage-based billing. tiun's $200 minimum payout means very small balances roll over to the next month, while Creem pays out twice a month from 50 USD/EUR.

Is there a European alternative to Paddle?

Creem is the only option here whose legal seller is always an EU company: Armitage Labs OÜ in Estonia. tiun is European but Swiss: tiun AG is based in Zürich, outside the EU, and processes data primarily in Switzerland and the EEA. Paddle sells through Paddle.com Market Ltd (UK) for most non-US sales, Paddle Payments Ltd (Ireland) if you are based in the UK or Isle of Man, and Paddle.com Inc. for US buyers.

How long does it take to switch from Paddle?

Paddle says it transfers payment method details within 2 weeks of your request and the new vault's security checks. Dodo Payments puts a full migration at 3 to 4 weeks. With providers that don't import cards, such as Creem, Stripe Managed Payments and tiun, subscribers move only when they check out again.

Will my subscribers have to re-enter their cards?

Not if the new provider imports Paddle's card data: Dodo Payments and Lemon Squeezy document this, and FastSpring and PayPro Global import payment data from a previous provider. Customers who pay with Apple Pay, Google Pay or another wallet will have to add a card again, according to Dodo's migration docs. With Creem, Stripe Managed Payments or tiun, every subscriber re-enters a payment method.

Summarize with AI